Skip to Content

Perseverance through challenges results in successful seniors housing business sale

We never could have made it through this process if we had attempted to do it on our own without the expertise of Plante Moran. We would not have had the resources to devote to the sale that Plante Moran was able to bring to the table. Plante Moran experts were trusted advisors guiding us through each step of the process. They understood our intentions and aims in selling the property. It was clear from start to finish that Plante Moran advocated on our behalf and always had our best interest in mind.
Sr. Julie Sewell, OSB
Prioress, Our Lady of Grace Monastery

The client

In 2019, the Sisters of St. Benedict made the difficult decision to sell their not-for-profit senior living campus, St. Paul Hermitage, which included independent living, assisted living, and skilled nursing offerings. Selling was a decision they knew would be right for the following reasons:

  • The increased complexity of healthcare since the facility’s beginning in 1961 to present day complicated the practice of running the facility.
  • St. Paul Hermitage faced many challenges as a stand-alone facility, especially with additional pressures and cost of the pandemic.
  • There were a number of sisters still employed by the facility who wished to exit their care roles.
  • The residents of the facility would benefit from the experience and resources a qualified buyer would bring as the new owner/operator.
  • A new owner/operator could operate the facility much more efficiently and position the operation for the long term, which will preserve the Sisters’ legacy in the community.

To help them navigate the process, the Sisters of St. Benedict engaged Plante Moran Realpoint (PMR), formerly Plante Moran REIA. PMR had been a trusted advisor to the sisters for many years prior as they discerned the future of their mission and charism. PMR’s in-house team consists of consultants with extensive experience helping both religious institutions and senior living providers with their business and real estate needs.

The challenges

As it turned out, PMR’s experience was necessary to overcome a variety of challenges and bring the project to a successful conclusion.

The COVID-19 pandemic was the most disruptive challenge, in that it added additional pressures to the facility’s operations and slowed down the market for senior living and care acquisitions. Postponing the disposition process until the economy improved was ultimately the best choice for the go-to-market strategy.

Other challenges stemmed from the uniqueness of St. Paul Hermitage itself. With 72 units, an atypical mix of acuity levels, and deferred maintenance, the facility was too small to benefit from economies of scale and would need strategic capital investment. In the offering memorandum, PMR presented the asset’s strengths and why its excellent reputation for high-quality care provided a new owner/operator with an opportunity for growth in top-line revenue, EBITDAR, and operating margin.

The solution

PMR’s proven process for dispositions begins with understanding our clients’ goals. For the Sisters of St. Benedict, their driving goal was to find a buyer who shared their values of providing quality care for the residents and excellent place to work for staff.

PMR initiated marketing efforts by identifying and presenting the unique characteristics of the facility to a prequalified universe of potential buyers, beginning with Catholic skilled nursing facility operators. We ultimately broadened outreach efforts to all accredited national investor and operator groups. Our team’s knowledge of the state’s complex regulatory environment and reimbursement programs — as well as the strengths of the facility itself and its local market — enabled us to be unmatched in our ability to guide interested buyers through questions.

As offers came in, PMR helped the sisters conduct a buyer suitability screening process to choose the buyer best aligned with their values. Once chosen, we advocated for deal terms often overlooked in Letter of Intent (LOI) negotiations that would benefit the sisters both financially and in closing the transaction quickly. Before the sale concluded, PMR facilitated a smooth transition to the new owners by coordinating replacement staff members as the sisters on staff phased out of their positions.

The benefit

The disposition process was not easy for the Sisters of St. Benedict given its many challenges. It took perseverance, determination, and the expert guidance from PMR to maneuver through a variety of obstacles to a successful close.

Fortunately, our many years of experience means PMR employs a well-developed disposition methodology with all our clients who wish to sell their operating business and real estate assets. This collaborative process confirms a strategy that aligns with their goals and needs. It ensures we offer white-glove service to position the facility for sale, manage communications between parties, and negotiate favorable terms. And through closing, it can help minimize surprises, reduce risk, and optimize outcomes.

PMR’s broad internal resources have multiple decades serving religious senior care and living clients with their operational, regulatory, development, and disposition needs. If you’re considering the selling your seniors housing business or another owned property, have us be your first call. We’ll help you through the process every step of the way. 

Want great space like this? Contact:

Benedictine Sisters of Chicago Image

Benedictine Sisters of Chicago

Chicago, IL

The Benedictine Sisters of Chicago needed expert guidance to assist them in community financial and ministry planning, determining options for healthcare and residential needs, and identifying reuse opportunities for their land given their land use preferences, financial realities, and residential needs.

Case Study / 3 min read

View project
View of Pious Society of St. Paul school building through tree branches.

Society of St. Paul

Dearborn, MI

The Society of St. Paul needed help in determining the best course of action for the deteriorating 1920s former school building used as a residence and publishing center.

Case Study / 1 min read

View project
Benedictine Sisters of Little Falls

Franciscan Sisters of Little Falls

Little Falls, MN

The Franciscan Sisters of Little Falls in Little Falls, Minnesota, needed a comprehensive real estate and demographics assessment to determine options for future planning.

Case Study / 1 min read

View project
Inside of a brightly lit church

Sisters of Mercy West Midwest


In 2008, six former regional communities came together to form the Sisters of Mercy West Midwest, who then sought to discover the condition and value of the community's facilities.

Case Study / 1 min read

View project
Felician Sisters Image

Felician Sisters of North America

Welland, Ontario

The Felician Sisters of North America sought to divest themselves of a former convent building in Welland, Ontario, and required an experienced advocate to make the sale successful.

Case Study / 1 min read

View project
Catherines Place Image

The Institute of the Sisters of Mercy of the Americas

Farmington Hills, MI

The sisters living at the McAuley Center in Farmington Hills required assistance to determine the feasibility of renovating an elder care facility and applying for licensed beds to care for aging members.

Case Study / 1 min read

View project